Skip to main content.

Accommodations in Shelter Island, New York

Search 34 Accommodations in Shelter Island

Save more with Secret Prices

Get instant savings with Secret Prices

  • Pay now or later on most rooms
  • Free cancellation on most rooms
  • Price Guarantee

Where to stay in Shelter Island

Shelter Island overview

Whatever your interests are, Shelter Island has something for you. Visitors to Shelter Island can take time to see places like Mashomack Preserve and Havens House. While you're in town, don't miss a chance to see sights like Shelter Island Whale's Tail and Sylvester Manor.

Where to stay in Shelter Island

Whether traveling on business or vacation, Shelter Island can comfortably accommodate all visitors. You can shop as many as 124 deals for Shelter Island accommodations on, some with discounts of up to 43%. We have room prices starting at 34 USD per night and below are the number of hotels by star rating in Shelter Island as well as in the surrounding area:
  • • 3 5-star hotels from 495 USD per night
  • • 42 4-star hotels from 162 USD per night
  • • 74 3-star hotels from 65 USD per night
  • • 29 2-star hotels from 45 USD per night

How to get to Shelter Island

Fly in to Islip, NY (ISP-MacArthur), 45.3 mi (72.9 km) from downtown Shelter Island. New York, NY (JFK-John F. Kennedy Intl.) is the next closest major airport, 82.2 mi (132.3 km) away.

What to see around Shelter Island

Nature lovers will appreciate these places:
  • • Mashomack Preserve
  • • Wades Beach
  • • Menhadden Lane Beach
  • • Shell Beach
Highlights of the area include:
  • • Mashomack Preserve
  • • Havens House
  • • Shelter Island Whale's Tail
  • • Sylvester Manor
  • • Gardiner's Bay Country Club

When to visit Shelter Island

If you're beginning to plan your holiday, you might be wondering when is the best time to visit. Here's a list of seasonal norms to help you arrange your travel schedule:

Seasonal temperature averages
  • • January-March: 52°F day, 19°F night
  • • April-June: 79°F day, 31°F night
  • • July-September: 81°F day, 46°F night
  • • October-December: 68°F day, 21°F night
Seasonal rainfall averages
  • • January-March: 11.22 inches
  • • April-June: 12.60 inches
  • • July-September: 11.54 inches
  • • October-December: 11.61 inches